Categories
Navigating Disputes

Who Bears the Burden of Proof When a Product Fails to Meet Contract Terms?

Dispute regarding the condition of the product upon arrival and whether the shipments comply with the terms of the contract

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) has developed a series of articles summarizing past arbitration decisions. These articles will help members understand how the DRC Dispute Rules and Standards (R&S) apply in a dispute.

The DRC Dispute R&S states that all DRC arbitrations are private and confidential. As such, the names of all parties, including arbitrators and companies, are not included. A reminder that the DRC’s sole role is to administer the arbitration process; the DRC does not participate in any hearings. Therefore, this summary is based solely on the arbitrator’s written decision and may not reflect important information shared with the arbitrator through written briefs or verbal testimony.

Abstract:

The dispute arose when the Respondent failed to pay the Claimant seven invoices within the agreed terms. The Respondent argued that payment was withheld because all seven loads arrived in deteriorated condition, with inconsistent sizing and greening.

The arbitrator found that the Respondent did not prove the product on six of the seven loads failed to meet DRC Good Arrival Guidelines or contract terms, nor that there was mutual agreement to alter the contract terms. The only modification confirmed applied to one specific load.

This summary provides an essential overview of the arbitration decision and its implications for international commercial disputes.

CASE: DRC File #19346 – Parties Domiciled – United States and Canada

Summary of Facts:

Claimant claims that it sold seven lots of medium #1 quality onions to Respondent represented by invoice numbers 132943 ($6,847.50), 132945 ($6,847.50), 132946 ($6,847.50), 133078 ($6,927.50), 133080 ($6,927.50), 133115 ($6,862.50), and 133116 ($6,847.50), and that it is owed $48,107.50 for the onions plus DRC fees and other costs for a total owed of $61,581.06. 

Respondent defends by claiming that all seven lots were defective with decay and had variable sizing and greening.

SUMMARY OF ARBITRATOR’S ANALYSIS AND REASONING:

Respondent acknowledges that it purchased and received all seven lots of onions. (Statement of Defence, paragraph “1”).  Under well-established law, Respondent owes Claimant the full agreed upon purchase prices for each lot less any provable damages.  Respondent has the burden of proof to show a breach of the contract to ship US#1 medium onions, and to establish the amount of its damages.

Invoice Numbers 132943, 132945, 132946, 133080

Respondent provides no evidence to establish a breach of contract with respect to the lots referenced by invoice numbers 132943, 132945, 132946, and 133080.  There are no trouble reports, and, most importantly, there are no inspections showing of the quality and condition of the subject onions on arrival.  Respondent’s repack reports are insufficient evidence to show a breach of contract since they do not show the condition of the onions at the time of arrival.  Without such evidence, Respondent cannot carry its burden of proof.  Thus, Claimant is owed the full amount of the agreed upon prices for these four invoices.

Invoice Numbers 133078, 133115, and 133116

Respondent reported trouble to Claimant on the three lots referenced by invoice numbers 133078 (PO #9764), 133115 (PO #9773), and 133116 (PO #9772), and Claimant responded by generating a “Trouble Notification” for each lot that said: “Onions Received with decay, variable sizing and greening.  Customer will work through product and advise on returns.”  (Exhibit “H”). 

The following email exchange took place between Respondent’s Mr. A and Claimant’s Mr. M over the next few days:  

7/16/14:

Email from Mr. A to Mr. M #133078 [PO #9764]

“J. Load received will require regarding and reworked in order to meet #1 grade required to pack and ship., we will rework the load and advise as to all necessary costs. Please acknowledge. Thank you.”

Email from Mr. M to Mr. A

“This is what I was afraid of. Could you please send an in-house inspection, so I have it for my grower. Once I have that documentation, we can grant full protection.” (Exhibit “L”). [Emphasis supplied].

7/22/14:

Email from Mr. A to Mr. M

“Subject: File #9773 [Invoice #133115] and 9772 [Invoice #133116]

J both of the attached files have arrived with the same problems. We will endeavor to repack regrade and hopefully bring the Onions to a #1 grade to sell. We will handle for your account. Please acknowledge.” (Exhibit “A”).

Email from Mr. M to Mr. A

“Re: File #9773 and 9772

Can you please send a in-house inspection and pictures? I never received a in-house inspection on the last order you asked for protection on either.” (Exhibit “M”). [Emphasis supplied].

Email from Mr. A to Mr. M

“Subject: Onions loads inspections

Label “YYY”

Date received: 07/19/2014

#1: 50.
#2: 32.
#3: 53.
#4: 42.
#5: 58.
#6: 70.
#7: 91.

Total: 396 bad ones out of 7 units.

Average: 56.5/unit. Fruit flies are all over

Inspected 7 – 50lbs bgs.

56.5% defects

Further inspections to follow

The above emails make clear that the parties agreed to amend their original FOB contracts on these three lots to become “full protection” contracts, but that was expressly contingent upon Respondent providing “in-house inspections.” Claimant said that the reason he needed the in-house inspections was: “so I have it for my grower.”

Respondent’s 7/22/14 email was in response to Claimant’s request for in-house inspections. The inspection was problematic: it was unclear which lot it was for, based on a small sample, and lacked defect details. Claimant did not object, so full protection applied. Respondent’s repack report showed a 68.5% loss, so Respondent owes Claimant $2,142 for invoice #133078.

For invoices #133115 and #133116, Respondent did not provide in-house inspections, so the original FOB contract terms apply. Without proper inspections or representative evidence, Respondent cannot prove a breach and must pay in full for these two lots.

Even if Claimant would have been found to have breached its contractual obligations to Respondent with respect to these two lots, Respondent did not provide Claimant with a proper accounting that shows the dates of sales of the repacked onions, the amounts sold, and the prices, and so would be found to have not proven its damages.

Claimant requests an award of interest, and for reimbursement for the DRC administrative fee and arbitrator’s fees in the amount of $2,700. The Arbitrator has the discretion as to whether to award such a request. Here, there is some evidence that Claimant may have breached its contractual obligations regarding the lots that are the subject of invoices #133115 and #133116, particularly the repacking reports. Respondent, though, is being required to pay those invoices in full due to a lack of sufficient documentation, particularly a lack of inspections. This creates the possibility that Claimant is receiving more than it would have if Respondent had properly documented matters. For that reason, the request for interest is denied. The request for reimbursement of the DRC fees, which is an out-of-pocket expense for Claimant, is granted in the amount of $2,700.

Respondent is found to owe Claimant the following amounts:

Invoice NumberAmount Owed
1132943$6,847.50
2132945$6,847.50
3132946$6,847.50
4133078$2,142.00
5133080$6,927.50
6133115$6,862.50
7133116$6,847.50
Subtotal:$43,322.00
DRC Fee:$2,700.00
Total: $46,022.00

Respondent requests a setoff for the claims made by Company C and Company S. There are multiple problems with this claim, including a lack of inspections and the lack of showing that the onions from the lot that is the subject of invoice #133078 are the ones objected to by those receivers. Accordingly, the request for a setoff is denied.

If Claimant breached its contractual obligations regarding one or more of the six lots for which full price is found to be owed, then this will be a harsh result.  Respondent should know that it becomes vital to obtain a proper inspection to show the condition and quality of perishable produce on arrival, or alternatively, to enter into an amended agreement and comply with that agreement. The most reliable inspections are done by trained third parties.  While parties can agree to use an “in-house inspection,” a receiver needs to be sure that such an inspection comes close to applying the standards used in an inspection performed by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. 

ARBITRATOR’S SUMMARY DECISION:

The Arbitrator reviewed the documents submitted by both parties and submitted his/her decision as follows:

Claimant shall recover from Respondent the sum of US$46,022.00. Respondent is hereby ordered to pay the Claimant US$46,022.00 no later than thirty (30) days from the date of this decision.

DRC COMMENTS:

There are two important issues to address in this case:

1. If the receiver’s intention is to claim damages for breach of contract due to a load received in deteriorated condition, the following steps are essential to meet the burden of proof in the event of a dispute:

  • Prompt Notification: Notify the shipper of an issue as soon as an issue is noticed upon arrival of the load.
  • Request an inspection: Unless a private or in-house inspection is agreed by the parties, request a government inspection within 8 working hours of arrival (excluding Sundays and holidays).
  • Share the Inspection report: Share the inspection results with the shipper within 24 hours of getting the report.
  • Mitigate losses: You must make every reasonable effort to market and sell the product as quickly as possible to minimize losses.
  • Account of Sales: While an account of sales or liquidation report is not required when claiming damages, this is the best method to show how the product was handled and which expenses were incurred due to the breach of contract. Make sure an itemized account of sales or liquidation report is provided.

2. DRC members should note that in both the US and Canada, a federal inspection is required when receiving product in deteriorated condition, unless both parties have explicitly agreed to another arrangement. The party relying on a private or in-house inspection, rather than a government inspection, must prove that such an agreement exists.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES:

To access the full redacted arbitration decision, click here.

Solutions Newsletter Articles

Need Help Navigating Fresh Produce Trade Disputes?

Contact the DRC for membership information and expert guidance on preventing and resolving disputes. 
Reach out to us today at info@fvdrc.com or visit www.fvdrc.com/contact to discover how we can help you 
trade with confidence anywhere in the world.

Categories
Uncategorized

Before You Ship: How Well Do You Know Your Customer?

We talk about this every single day here at the office. We question how companies get hooked into heavy financial losses or find themselves in a complicated bind. The answer almost always follows the same pattern: assuming you know enough about your customer.

With proactive due diligence—and the backing of the Fruit & Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC)—you can protect your produce business from unnecessary risk. Whether you are a seasoned veteran, a brand-new member, or evaluating how to safeguard your next transaction, make these core steps a part of every trade:

1. Verify DRC Membership First

Is your customer or prospect a DRC member? If you aren’t sure, treat it as an immediate red flag. Visit our website to search our public member list, or contact our office directly if you need help. (Non-members can take advantage of our public tools, but full members enjoy seamless access to our team to run these checks instantly!)

2. Confirm Good Standing, Not Just Membership

Finding a name on our list is a great start, but is the member in good standing? Members can reach out to our Trading Assistance Team to verify current standing and receive valuable guidance before finalizing a sale and shipping product.

3. Vet Your References Thoroughly

Never skip checking references. A reference is only as good as its reputation; many firms discover too late that a reference provided is nonexistent or unreliable.

4. Confirm Who You Are Actually Dealing With

Verify that anyone contacting you on behalf of a company is an employee or authorized representative—not an unverified intermediary.

  • Confirm their identity through the company’s website, staff directory, or member portal.
  • Contact the company directly using official contact information.
  • Ask to be connected through the company’s switchboard or internal extension
  • If you are a Blue Book Member, check their Blue Book Verify Tool, which confirms the identity of potential trading partners.

5. Look Into Blue Book Services

Is your trading partner listed and rated in Blue Book Services? If not, ask yourself why. Unlisted firms may be brand new or handling minimal volumes. Listed and not rated can also be a red flag.

6. Check: The Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA)

If your trading partner operates in the United States, consult the PACA database to review the license status of each company, including trade name(s), branch location(s), principal(s), and other license related information.

7. Dig Deeper into Credit Ratings

Don’t assume an unrated listing means business as usual. It often means the company isn’t rated or lacks enough file history to establish a score.

8. Match the Paperwork

Do the phone numbers, addresses, personnel, and EXACT company name match up with DRC’s records? If they don’t, this could be another red flag.

9. Insist on Arbitration Agreements

If you are doing business with a non-member, do they at least have a DRC arbitration agreement in place? Without one, you leave yourself exposed to high costs and legal vulnerabilities if challenges arise.

10. Keep Clear, Detailed Records

In a dispute, proper documentation is everything. Always retain copies of your purchase orders, invoices, inspection reports, and written communications. Having a clear paper trail makes resolution through the DRC much faster and smoother.

Don’t Face Trade Disputes Alone

Time and again, experience shows that many disputes could easily have been avoided by checking with the DRC and practicing a little upfront due diligence before the sale. Everybody takes a calculated chance occasionally, but navigating the produce industry without a risk mitigation partner is a gamble your bottom line shouldn’t have to take.

Not yet a member?

Discover how a DRC membership pays for itself the very first time a dispute is avoided. Visit our website to learn more about membership benefits, or contact DRC’s Member Services today.

We look forward to helping your business trade with confidence!

Categories
Membership Update

Membership Update for October 2026

Summary: Membership Update

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) welcomed 11 new members in October 2026. Additionally, some existing members have changed their membership status, including one termination. Scroll below for more information.

Welcome New Members

ACTIVATION HOLDINGS LTD. (Also d/b/a Active Greens) BC Canada
AFRICAN FOODWAYS MARKET LTD. MB Canada
ALIMENTS FONTAINE SANTÉ INC. / FONTAINE SANTÉ FOODS INC. QC Canada
BLUESKY HYDROPONICS INC. ON Canada
GOLDEN LEAF (A d/b/a of 11597124 Canada Inc.) ON Canada
H-MART EDMONTON INC. AB Canada
LES VERGERS CATAPHARD & FILS INC. QC Canada
OBVIOUS FRUITS INC. BC Canada
PRIME IMPORTS (A d/b/a of 9566-7424 QUEBEC INC.) QC Canada
RED EYE GROUP LLC. Delaware United States
UNIPORT DISTRIBUTION (A d/b/a of 1001509548 Ontario Inc.) ON Canada

DRC Membership Change in Status

As of October 31st, 2026, the following organizations no longer hold a DRC membership:

17056362 CANADA INC., ON, Canada
9548-4192 QUEBEC INC., QC, Canada
BURROWING OWL VINEYARDS LTD. (Also d/b/a Burrowing Owl Estate, BC, Canada
EXELLAR TRANSPORTATION INC., ON, Canada
HURTANAVA PRODUCE LLC, TX, United States
JUST AVOCADO PRODUCE MICHOACAN S.A. DE C.V. (También haciendo negocios como Avocadox), Michoacan, Mexico
JV FRESH PRODUCE (A d/b/a of 16928820 Canada Inc.), ON, Canada
LIGHT SPEED LOGISTICS INC., AB, Canada
MAVERICK ESTATE WINERY INC. (Also d/b/a Maverick Estate Winery), BC, Canada
MN BUSINESS INC., QC, Canada
NILE GARDENS INC., ON, Canada
NILE MAPLE TRADERS INCORPORATED, NB, Canada
O’ROURKE FAMILY VINEYARDS LTD., BC, Canada
OYAY INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, ON, Canada
PEPPERTREE GREENHOUSES LTD., ON, Canada
PROCESOS AGROINDUSTRIALES S.A. (También haciendo negocios como Proagro), Lima, Peru
RIVER STONE ESTATE WINERY INC. (Also d/b/a River Stone Estate Winery), BC, Canada
SMART-LINK HOMEWARE PRODUCTS INC., ON, Canada
ZOE FOOD AND ORGANICS (A d/b/a of Zoe Organic Foods and Inorganic Corporation), ON, Canada

Termination with Cause

Light Speed Logistics Inc. was terminated from the DRC membership effective October 23, 2026, following receivership.

Important note: Following membership termination, the former member remains liable for claims arising prior to their termination if the claim is submitted to DRC by way of a Notice of Dispute within nine (9) months from when the claim arose or within nine (9) months from when the claimant ought reasonably to have known of its existence.

For questions about membership changes, contact our Help Desk.

About the DRC

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) is a not-for-profit membership-based entity whose core work is business-to-business commercial dispute resolution for the fresh produce industry. The DRC serves as a referee between parties when a purchase and sale do not go according to plan. Members follow a common set of trading standards and responsibilities that promote fair and ethical trading for produce entering the North American marketplace. In Canada, membership in the DRC is a regulatory requirement to trade fresh fruits and vegetables (i.e., buy, sell, import, or export) unless exempt under the regulations. The DRC has members in 18 countries, and membership continues to grow annually. Anyone exporting fresh fruits and vegetables to Canada must sell to a DRC member.

In addition to its Operating Rules and Trading Standards, the DRC offers a comprehensive, tailored suite of tools to build members’ knowledge and capacity to avoid or resolve disputes. The DRC provides education, mediation, and arbitration services, and can impose sanctions and disciplinary actions on members who fail to conduct business in accordance with the terms of their membership agreement.

The DRC has resolved claims worth more than $105 million. Although arbitration is available, 80% of these claims have been settled in an average of 26 days through our informal consultation and mediation services. Arbitration awards are court-enforceable in countries that are signatories to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards or subsequent conventions.

For more information about our members and membership with the DRC, click here.

Categories
Video and Webinars

Building Better Trading Partnerships: Lessons from Orlando

At the 2026 Global Produce and Floral Show in Orlando, Jaime Bustamante joined Patrick Kelly of Ag Life Media to discuss how clear communication and DRC’s four pillars of trade standards help strengthen partnerships and protect your bottom line.

Discover the essential tools for success.

Categories
Uncategorized

Does DRC allow its members to offset payment from undisputed invoices?

Offsetting payment from undisputed or unrelated invoices is common in our industry. DRC’s Trading Assistance Staff continues to receive inquiries or cases connected to this practice. The question remains: does DRC allow offsetting payment from undisputed invoices?

The most common examples of offsets come from receivers receiving a load in deteriorated condition, where losses after claiming damages exceed the original invoiced price. This leads receivers to deduct those losses from other unrelated transactions. Another example occurs with transportation accounts, where shippers or receivers withhold payment to transportation companies on freight bills totalling the load’s value because of a carrier claim tied to only one transaction.

Technically, unless shippers, receivers and transportation companies have an agreement to offset accounts, the receiver is not automatically entitled to offset their losses on unrelated produce or freight invoices.

While DRC Trading Standards and Transportation Standards are silent regarding offsetting payments from undisputed or unrelated accounts, these standards are both clear about payment practices if payment terms have not been agreed to:

Trading Standards

“Definitions – Section 19.10.5

(5). Payment for produce purchased by a buyer, within 10 days after the day on which the produce is accepted:”

Transportation Standards

“Claims – Section 10.3 and 10.4

3. Carrier not at Fault

If it is clear that responsibility for the loss damage is not related to the contract of carriage, the carriage charges should be paid in full. The carrier should not be compelled to await payment of its freight charges pending the outcome of any dispute between the buyer and seller. The carrier has fulfilled its responsibility and deserves to be paid the full amount of its charges.

4. Carrier at Fault

Where it is evident that the fault is with the carrier, the most practical and fair procedure is to seek an immediate understanding concerning payment of a claim in the proven amount.  When the measure of damages may not be determined precisely until the merchandise is sold, arrangements should be made between carrier and receiver concerning the time and method of selling the produce and when payment of any balance of freight charges is to be made to the carrier.  Should the parties fail to reach an agreement the dispute can be submitted to the Corporation for resolution under its rules.”

If a produce or freight transaction does not have a contract that specifically allows offsets, it is treated as a separate agreement. Without a contract, each transaction is treated individually, especially in the event of a dispute.

Provided that the receiver and the transportation company are DRC members, if losses are beyond the shipper’s invoice price plus freight, and the receiver or the transportation company refuse to pay, a claim can be filed with DRC to try to collect those losses.

Have questions about offsetting payments or DRC contract terms? Contact the DRC’s Trading Assistance Staff for expert guidance or to review your current agreements to ensure compliance with DRC rules.

Categories
Uncategorized

Membership Update for September 2026

Summary: Membership Update

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) welcomed 11 new members in September 2026. Additionally, some existing members have changed their membership status, including one termination. Scroll below for more information.

Welcome New Members

1590461 BC LTD., BC, Canada
AGROBOXMC (A d/b/a of Jorge Enrique Escudero Contreras), ON, Canada
AGROINVERSIONES POSTILLOS E.I.R.L., Lima, Peru
AVOCAMPOS RICO DE MEXICO SPR DE RL DE CV (También haciendo negocios como Campomex), Jalisco, Mexico
BORRELLI WINES LTD., ON, Canada
CDMG BUSINESS LTD., BC, Canada
DIRECTAGRI CONNECT INC., QC, Canada
ERARSLANLAR SOGUK HAVA DEPOSU TARIM HAYVANCILIK NAKLIYAT SAN, Denizli, Turkey
KYLE A. PRODUCE (A d/b/a of Kyle Andrew Azevedo), ON, Canada
NUAGE LOGISTICS INC., QC, Canada
SAVEURS ET PRESTIGE INC., QC, Canada

DRC Membership Change in Status

As of September 3oth, 2026, the following organizations no longer hold a DRC membership:

9457-9885 QUÉBEC INC., QC, Canada
AMPLE PRODUCE INC. (Also d/b/a Ample Harvest), ON, Canada
ARTUS BOTTLING LTD., BC, Canada
KIKAPO TROPICAL FOODS INC., AB, Canada
SANDHU GREEN VEG AND FOODS LTD., ON, Canada
SKYWOC INDUSTRIES CANADA INC., ON, Canada
VENTURA DISTRIBUTION (A d/b/a of 9029-7086 Québec Inc.), QC, Canada

Termination with Cause

VENTURA DISTRIBUTION (A d/b/a of 9029-7086 Québec Inc.) was terminated from the DRC membership effective September 9, 2026, for having filed an assignment in bankruptcy.

Important note: Following membership termination, the former member remains liable for claims arising prior to their termination if the claim is submitted to DRC by way of a Notice of Dispute within nine (9) months from when the claim arose or within nine (9) months from when the claimant ought reasonably to have known of its existence.

For questions about membership changes, contact our Help Desk.

About the DRC

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) is a not-for-profit membership-based entity whose core work is business-to-business commercial dispute resolution for the fresh produce industry. The DRC serves as a referee between parties when a purchase and sale do not go according to plan. Members follow a common set of trading standards and responsibilities that promote fair and ethical trading for produce entering the North American marketplace. In Canada, membership in the DRC is a regulatory requirement to trade fresh fruits and vegetables (i.e., buy, sell, import, or export) unless exempt under the regulations. The DRC has members in 18 countries, and membership continues to grow annually. Anyone exporting fresh fruits and vegetables to Canada must sell to a DRC member.

In addition to its Operating Rules and Trading Standards, the DRC offers a comprehensive, tailored suite of tools to build members’ knowledge and capacity to avoid or resolve disputes. The DRC provides education, mediation, and arbitration services, and can impose sanctions and disciplinary actions on members who fail to conduct business in accordance with the terms of their membership agreement.

The DRC has resolved claims worth more than $105 million. Although arbitration is available, 80% of these claims have been settled in an average of 26 days through our informal consultation and mediation services. Arbitration awards are court-enforceable in countries that are signatories to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards or subsequent conventions.

For more information about our members and membership with the DRC, click here.

Categories
Uncategorized

Reject or Accept and Claim Damages? Arbitration Insights from a Red Onion Case

Dispute concerning an adequate return offered after receiving a product that does not comply with the contract terms.

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) has developed a series of articles summarizing past arbitration decisions. These articles will help members understand how the DRC Dispute Rules and Standards (R&S) apply in a dispute.

The DRC Dispute R&S states that all DRC arbitrations are private and confidential. As such, the names of all parties, including arbitrators and companies, are not included. A reminder that the DRC’s sole role is to administer the arbitration process; the DRC does not participate in any hearings. Therefore, this summary is based solely on the arbitrator’s written decision and may not reflect important information shared with the arbitrator through written briefs or verbal testimony.

Abstract:

The arbitration decision concerns a dispute between parties in the United States and Canada. The conflict arose when the Claimant received the Account of Sales prepared by the Respondent’s customer for two loads of red onions. The Respondent contended that these two shipments did not meet the contract terms, prompting them to seek damages for the loads.

The arbitrator concluded that the Respondent did not provide sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the return offered by the Respondent’s customer for the two loads was reasonable, based on the results outlined in the inspection certificates.

This summary provides an essential overview of the arbitration decision and its implications for international commercial disputes.

CASE: DRC File #18587 – Parties Domiciled – United States and Canada

Summary of Facts (SOF)

The matter in dispute involves two truck shipments of red onions shipped by the Claimant from Hatch, New Mexico to the Respondent at the agreed destination of Montreal, Quebec on June 22 and 23, 2009.

Claimant’s Invoice #9310

The Claimant sold to the Respondent a total of 1,680 25 lb. bags of Jumbo Red Onions at CA$7.50 FOB plus “Temp” at CA$8.00, Shipping Point Inspection Fee of CA$110.00 and 21 pallets at CA$6.00 for an invoice total of CA$12,844.00. The Claimant shipped the onions to the Respondent’s customer in Montreal on June 22, 2009, on an unrefrigerated truck. The Bill of Lading reads, in part, “Tarp onions, but roll tarp up on both ends (front and back). Keep onions dry and well ventilated. Keep free of rain and smoke.”

This shipment apparently arrived sometime on Friday, June 26. The Respondent filed a request for inspection shortly after 8 AM on Saturday, June 27. A CFIA inspection was made on Monday, June 29, and revealed that the onions contained an average of 9% decay, with a range of 4-18%. The pulp temperature of the onions was reported as 12ºC (54ºF).

On July 6, the Respondent forwarded the Claimant an accounting of sales and expenses prepared by Respondent’s customer. The accounting reads as follows:

800 bags sold at CA$8.00CA$6,400.00
400 bags sold at CA$7.50CA$3,000.00
480 bags sold at CA$6.50CA$3,120.00
Total Sales:CA$12,520.00
Exchange 1.19%US$10,521.00
Expenses
Freight (1680 X US$3.50)US$5,880.00
Destination InspectionUS$252.00
Commissions (10% of sales)US$1,052.00
Total ExpensesUS$7,184.00
Due Shipper: (US$10,521.00 – US$7,184.00)US$3,337.00

Claimant’s Invoice #9310

The Claimant sold to the Respondent a total of 1,680 25 lb. bags of Jumbo Red Onions at CA$7.50 FOB plus Inspection Fees of $110.00 and 21 pallets at CA$6.00 for an invoice total of CA$12,836.00, and shipped them to the Respondent’s customer in Montreal on June 23, on an unrefrigerated truck. The Bill of Lading reads, in part, “Tarp onions, but roll tarp up on both ends (front and back). Keep onions dry and well ventilated. Keep free of rain and smoke.”

This shipment apparently arrived sometime early on Saturday, June 27. The Respondent filed a request for inspection shortly after 8 AM on Monday, June 29. A CFIA inspection was made immediately and revealed that the onions contained an average of 19% decay, with a range of 11-29%. Pulp temperatures ranged from 24ºC (75ºF) to 26ºC (79ºF). The temperature in the warehouse was recorded as 22ºC (72ºF).

On July 6, the Respondent forwarded the Claimant an accounting of sales and expenses prepared by Respondent’s customer. The accounting reads as follows:

400 bags sold at CA$3.50CA$1,400.00
640 bags sold at CA$3.00CA$1,920.00
600 bags sold at CA$2.50CA$1,500.00
Total SalesCA$4,820.00
Exchange at 1.19%US$4,050.00
Expenses
Freight (1680 X US$3.50)US$5,880.00
Destination InspectionUS$252.00
Commissions (10% of sales)US$405.00
Total ExpensesUS$6,537.00

Due Receiver: (US$4,050.00 – 6,537.00) = Loss: (US$2,487.00)

The Claimant seeks a net total of US$22,278.00 for the two shipments, after an allowance of US$3,402.00 for decay.

SUMMARY OF ARBITRATOR’S ANALYSIS AND REASONING:

The dispute involves two separate loads of onions, and the arbitrator has discussed each load individually.

Claimant’s Invoice #9309

The parties are in agreement regarding the terms of sale and shipment up to the time the load arrived at the destination in Montreal. Although the file reflects that discussions took place between representatives of the two parties regarding the disposition of the load after it arrived, there is no evidence offered that establishes a clear rejection of the product by the Respondent.

The parties differ as to whether the Claimant agreed to move the product to another receiver, but as the party making the claim, the Respondent had the burden of proving this assertion. Again, there is no clear evidence that the Claimant agreed to void the contract and move the onions elsewhere. In addition, at the time the CFIA inspector arrived, the onions had been unloaded into the Respondent’s customer’s warehouse, an act of acceptance by the Respondent. Therefore, the arbitrator concludes that the Respondent received and accepted the onions and is responsible for paying the invoice amount, minus any damages incurred due to the Claimant’s breach of contract.

It is clear that the Claimant did, in fact, ship onions that failed to meet the FOB no-grade contract terms. The onions arrived at destination showing 9% decay, with a range of 4-18%. For FOB shipments such as this one, the DRC Good Arrival Guidelines establish a maximum tolerance for decay at destination of 4%. There is nothing that would establish carrier mishandling, and Respondent is therefore entitled to recover the damages it suffered as a result of Claimant’s breach.

The preferred method for calculating damages from a breach of contract is to compare the market value of a product meeting contract requirements against the actual sales price obtained from the sale of the damaged goods. In this case, there were no market quotes available for New Mexico red onions in the Montreal market at the time the onions were sold, so we must seek an alternative measure of the value of goods that meet the contract terms.

The first preferred alternative is to compare the delivered value of the product to the actual sales price obtained from the prompt and proper sale of the damaged goods. The accounting was issued seven days after inspection, and nothing would establish improper handling of the sales on the part of Respondent’s customer. In this instance, we have information regarding the freight charge, which appears on Respondent’s customer accounting and, in the absence of a freight bill, is accepted as a reasonable amount. The calculation of damages is as follows:

Market Value
1,680 X US$7.50 FOBUS$12,600.00
Shipping Point Inspection FeeUS$110.00
PalletsUS$126.00
FreightUS$5,880.00
Total Market ValueUS$18,716.00*
Less Gross Sales(US$10,521.00)
Basic DamagesUS$8,195.00
Plus Destination InspectionUS$252.00
Total DamagesUS$8,447.00

The Claimant’s invoice total was US$12,836.00*. Subtracting the Respondent’s damages of US$8,447.00 leaves a balance of US$4,389.00 due and unpaid.

*There is a US$8.00 charge on the Claimant’s invoice for “Temp”. This was apparently for a temperature recorder. Respondent states that there was no recorder on the load, and that none was called for on this non-refrigerated load. The arbitrator agreed and eliminated this charge from the delivered value of the shipment and from the invoice total.

Claimant’s Invoice #9310

The parties are in agreement regarding the terms of sale and shipment up to the time the load arrived at destination in Montreal. The file reflects that discussions took place between representatives of the two parties regarding the disposition of the load, but there is no evidence offered that establishes a clear rejection of the product by the Respondent.

The parties differ as to whether the Claimant agreed to move the product to another receiver, but as the party making the claim, the Respondent had the burden of proving this assertion. Again, there is no clear evidence in the record that the Claimant was willing to void the contract and move the onions elsewhere. In addition, at the time the CFIA inspector arrived, the onions had been unloaded into the Respondent’s client warehouse, an act of acceptance by the Respondent. Therefore, the arbitrator concluded that the Respondent received and accepted the onions and is responsible for paying the invoice amount, minus any damages incurred due to the Claimant’s breach of contract.

It is clear that the Claimant did, in fact, ship onions that failed to meet the FOB no-grade contract terms. The onions arrived at destination showing 19% decay, with a range of 11-29%. For FOB shipments such as this one, the DRC Good Arrival Guidelines establish a maximum tolerance for decay at destination of 4%. There is nothing to prove mishandling by the carrier, and Respondent is therefore entitled to recover the damages it suffered as a result of Claimant’s breach.

The Claimant notes that the pulp temperatures recorded during the inspection are considerably higher than those from the previous load. While this is true, the shipment was in the Respondent’s customer’s warehouse for one day less than the first load, and the fact that the load was shipped in an open truck from New Mexico to Quebec at the end of June indicates that the Claimant did not consider the onions particularly temperature-sensitive. In addition, given the extremely high degree of decay found in the onions, it is likely that the decay process itself elevated the pulp temperatures somewhat.

As in the case of the first load, the preferred method for calculating damages from a breach of contract is to compare the market value of good condition product against the actual sales price obtained from the prompt and proper sale of the damaged goods. The accounting was issued seven days after inspection, and there is nothing that would establish improper handling of the sales on the part of Respondent’s customer. Since the extent of decay in the onions was nearly five times the allowable tolerance, it is not unusual that the sales value of the onions would be drastically lower than might have been expected for product meeting contract. Again, there are no market quotes available for New Mexico red onions on the Montreal market at the time the onions were being sold, so we must seek an alternative measure of the value of goods meeting contract terms.

As before, the first alternative is to compare the delivered value of the product to the actual sales. Again, we have information regarding the freight charge, which appears on Respondent’s customer’s accounting, which, in the absence of a freight bill, is accepted as a reasonable amount. The calculation of damages is as follows:

Market Value
1,680 X US$7.50 FOBUS$12,600.00
Shipping Point Inspection FeeUS$110.00
PalletsUS$126.00
FreightUS$5,880.00
Total Market ValueUS$18,716.00*
Less Gross Sales(US$4,050.00)
Basic DamagesUS$14,666.00
Plus Destination InspectionUS$252.00
Total DamagesUS$14,918.00

Claimant’s invoice total was US$12,836.00. Subtracting Respondent’s damages of US$14,918.00 leaves a loss of US$2,082.00, for which Claimant is liable to Respondent.

Arbitrator’s Summary Decision

Claimant’s Invoice #9309

The Respondent is found liable to the Claimant for a total of US$4,389.00.

Claimant’s Invoice #9310

The Claimant is found liable to the Respondent for a total of US$2,082.00.

As a result, the Respondent is ordered to pay the remaining balance of US$2,307.00 within 30 days of this order. This amount is only US$1,457.00 more than what the Respondent initially offered. Since the Respondent has effectively prevailed in this matter, no award will be granted for the Claimant’s filing fees.

DRC Comments

There are two main takeaways from this decision. First, properly understand the difference between a rejection and an act of acceptance. The second is to ensure that, when submitting an account of sales, it complies with the requirements.

Acceptance and Regection

On a FOB transaction, a term that is defined in DRC Trade Standards Section 20, a receiver can proceed to reject a load if it has not committed an act of acceptance as defined in DRC Trade Standards Section 19:

“Acceptance” means:

(1) Any act by the consignee signifying acceptance of the shipment, including diversion or unloading, except for the purposes of inspection under the supervision of a recognized inspector;

(2) Any act by the consignee which is inconsistent with the consignor’s ownership, but if such act is wrongful against the consignor it is acceptance only if ratified by him; or

(3) Failure of the consignee to give notice of rejection to the consignor within a reasonable time: Provided, that acceptance shall not affect any claim for damages because of failure of the produce to meet the terms of the contract.”

To legally reject a load, proper justification is required, such as:

i. Evidence of a breach of contract in a timely manner, such as an inspection report confirming the breach
ii. Timely and proper notice of the intention to reject the load
iii. Have not committed an act of acceptance

In this case, the arbitrator decided that a proper rejection was not made.

Account of Sales

Because expedited arbitration proceedings only required the arbitrator to issue a limited reason decision, we can observe that the arbitrator used the information provided in the Respondent’s account of sales, but calculated damages differently. We assume the arbitrator proceeded this way because there was one element in the Respondent’s account of sales that failed to comply with the claim for damages, which is the “commission” expense. A commission is only warranted when the transaction is based on consignment terms, or the parties agree to change the contract from a fixed price to a consignment.

In this case, the arbitrator’s calculations were not far from the Respondent’s Account of Sales results.

This case also highlights the importance of a proper account of sales and understanding the distinction between acceptance and rejection, as that decision often determines the rights, obligations, and potential damages available to the parties. For a more detailed discussion of these concepts, see the article titled Accept or Reject linked below.

Additional Resources

To access the full redacted arbitration decision, click here.

Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation Trading Standards s. 10

Solutions Newsletter Articles

Accept or Reject

Dealing with Bad Load? Your Options as a Buyer/Receiver Revealed

Discussed, Understood and Agreed (DUA)

Claimant Damages: The Power of an Itemized Accounting of Sales

Need Help Navigating Fresh Produce Trade Disputes?

Contact the DRC for membership information and expert guidance on preventing and resolving disputes. 
Reach out to us today at info@fvdrc.com or visit www.fvdrc.com/contact to discover how we can help you 
trade with confidence anywhere in the world.

Categories
Uncategorized

Membership Update for August 2026

Summary: Membership Update

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) welcomed 10 new members in August 2026. Additionally, some existing members have changed their membership status. Scroll below for more information.

Welcome New Members

AGROCAMPO (A d/b/a of Edmundo Murrieta Martin del Campo), BC, Canada
BEAU SOLEIL DR INC., QC, Canada
FERME J. OUIMET INC., QC, Canada
NATIONAL PACKERS (A d/b/a of 9462-0705 Quebec Inc.), QC, Canada
OBRA AFRICAN FOODS INC., ON, Canada
RICO’S PRODUCE, LLC, FL, United States
VERTICAL FOODS LLC, CA, United States
VHM GLOBAL TRADING LTD., SK, Canada
VICAFRUIT PRODUCE LLC., TX, United States
XIAMAN PRODUCE (A d/b/a of 1582004 B.C. LTD.), BC, Canada

DRC Membership Change in Status

As of August 31st, 2026, the following organizations no longer hold a DRC membership:

AVON GROUP LTD., ON, Canada
CANADIAN GINSENG FOOD INC., ON, Canada
CANNEBERGES BIELER INC. / BIELER CRANBERRIES INC., QC, Canada
COMMERCE O’MALLEY QUÉBEC (Faisant également affaire sous Coulibaly Firmin), QC, Canada
GO GREEN CANADA EXIM LTD., ON, Canada
GOLESTAN MARKET FOOD INC. (Also d/b/a Golestan), BC, Canada
ROCK ROAD FARM LLC, WA, United States
URVIL LOGISTICS INC., BC, Canada
VF TRADE FRESH INC., ON, Canada

About the DRC

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) is a not-for-profit membership-based entity whose core work is business-to-business commercial dispute resolution for the fresh produce industry. The DRC serves as a referee between parties when a purchase and sale do not go according to plan. Members adhere to a common set of trading standards and member responsibilities that promote fair and ethical trading for produce entering the North American marketplace. In Canada, membership in the DRC is a regulatory requirement to trade fresh fruits and vegetables (i.e., buy, sell, import, or export) unless exempt under the regulations. The DRC has members in 19 countries, and membership continues to grow annually. Anyone exporting fresh fruits and vegetables to Canada must sell to a member of the DRC.

In addition to its Operating Rules and Trading Standards, the DRC offers a comprehensive, tailored suite of tools to build members’ knowledge and capacity to avoid or resolve disputes. The DRC provides education, mediation, and arbitration services, and can impose sanctions and disciplinary actions on members who fail to conduct business in accordance with the terms of their membership agreement.

The DRC has resolved claims worth more than $105 million. Although arbitration is available, 80% of these claims have been settled in an average of 26 days through our informal consultation and mediation services. Arbitration awards are court-enforceable in countries that are signatories to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards or subsequent conventions.

For more information about our members and membership with the DRC, click here.

Categories
Uncategorized

Representative Sample: Key to Reliable Inspections

Under the Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) Good Inspection Guidelines, unless otherwise agreed, DRC members who receive product in a deteriorated condition must request a third-party quality inspection, preferably a government inspection, to demonstrate that the product fails to meet the agreed-upon quality standard (specs) or the DRC Good Arrival Guidelines. While there are many elements to consider when requesting an inspection, one of the most important factors for a receiver is ensuring that a representative sample of the load is available when the inspector arrives.

How is a representative sample determined?

For DRC purposes, unless otherwise agreed, a useful rule of thumb comes from the Canadian Food Inspection Agency’s “appeal inspection” requirements. To qualify for an appeal inspection, more than 75% of the load must be available for inspection. Otherwise, if less than 75% of the load remains, an appeal inspection cannot be conducted because the remaining product is not considered a representative sample.

Additionally, the percentage of the product not available for inspection is normally considered to be in sound condition.

What if less than 75% of the load is available for inspection?

If less than 75% of the shipment remains available for inspection, contact the shipper or seller immediately and let them know the reasons why you are unable to have the full load available for inspection.

The parties should discuss whether the quantity remaining can still be considered representative of the full load. Another option is for the receiver to pay in full for the percentage of the product that is not available for inspection and offer to claim damages on the percentage of the load remaining, provided the inspection shows that the product fails to meet the agreed-upon quality standard (specs) or DRC Good Arrival Guidelines.

Handling product before an inspection

Receivers should exercise caution when moving, reselling, or otherwise handling produce before an inspection takes place.

If part of a shipment has already been sold to customers and those customers later reject the product, obtaining an inspection after the product is returned may not preserve the receiver’s rights against the shipper or seller. Even if the full quantity is recovered, the product may be considered “handled,” and it may be argued that the shipment has lost its identity after leaving the receiver’s control and being returned.

For this reason, receivers should arrange for an inspection as soon as a quality problem is discovered and before significant portions of the shipment are sold, moved, or otherwise handled.

Key Takeaway

When quality concerns arise, a timely inspection is critical. Equally important is ensuring that enough of the shipment remains available to constitute a representative sample. Without one, a receiver may face significant challenges in proving a claim and recovering losses from the shipper or seller.

If you have any questions about the article and would like to learn more, our team at the DRC is here to assist you. We value your inquiries and are eager to provide support. Click here to proceed.

Categories
Uncategorized

The inside story of a reefer: how air moves

One of the most common sources of disputes in the fresh produce industry involves temperature management during transportation. Understanding how refrigerated trailers function—and how airflow, loading practices, equipment condition, and monitoring affect product quality—can help reduce risk and prevent costly claims. Originally researched and written by Karen Davidson, Editor of The Grower publication, this article provides practical guidance for those involved in transporting fresh fruits and vegetables.

The reefer download shows a flat 36°F for the entire run, pickup to delivery.

You open the trailer at the dock, pull a clamshell from three rows deep, slide in a probe, and it reads 48°F. The rejection email is already in your inbox.

So which number is wrong?

Neither.

refrigeration

The reefer temperature measures the air circulating back to the evaporator. Your probe is measuring the pulp temperature of the fruit. Two different readings, two different stories, and on a load where airflow can’t reach every pallet, they often disagree by a lot. And you’re the one footing the bill in the process. That said, most of the causes are mechanical, physical, and procedural–and easily fixable once you can see them.

Why doesn’t the reefer set point match the product temperature?

Short answer: they’re measuring two different things, and the reefer was never built to tell you what the pulp is doing. Part of the trouble is a vocabulary problem. Four different temperatures get treated as one number on the dock, and they are not the same:

  1. Set point: What you dialed in: an instruction, not a measurement.
  2. Supply air: The chilled air leaving the evaporator, on its way into the box.
  3. Return air: The air coming back to the unit after it has moved through the load.
  4. Product temperature: What a probe reads when you push it into the pulp.

The reefer manages air. It can’t read the middle of a pallet three rows deep, and most units are built to keep cold products cold, not chase down heat the shipper sent in warm. So the trailer holds set point while a warm pallet in the nose takes hours to catch up, and hot spots build in dead zones the return-air sensor never sees.

That’s why one reading, stripped of context, sends you after the wrong problem. When air and pulp disagree, check the load, the precool, and the airflow before anyone blames the box.

How does air actually move through a refrigerated trailer?

Airflow is where most of the trouble hides, so it helps to picture the loop before worrying about what any sensor reads inside it. Cold air leaves the unit at the front top of the trailer, runs the length of the ceiling, drops over the load, picks up heat, and returns along the floor to the evaporator. Then the cycle starts again.

That loop only works, though, if the load gives the air somewhere to go, and a few common loading habits can shut it down:

  • Pallets jammed against the walls choke the sides and pinch off the downward path.
  • Product blocking the floor channels chokes the return and starves the evaporator of warm air to work on.
  • A load stacked too tall crowds the ceiling and keeps supply air from reaching the rear. Any one of those turns the back of the trailer into a dead zone, which is where the air chute earns its keep. A good chute carries cold air past the front pallets, and delivers it to the door end before it runs out of push.

Without one, or with a shortened one, the rear of the load drifts warm for the entire trip while the temperature log still looks clean.

What are the most common reasons a sensor reads warmer or colder than expected?

Once the airflow picture is clear, the next question is what trips it up on real loads. Most discrepancies trace back to a short list of very fixable causes.

  • The trailer wasn’t precooled: The GCCA calls precooling a baseline practice, and for good reason. Loading cold products into a warm box transfers heat straight into the pallets before the doors close. Set point alone does not confirm precool. Someone has to verify the air temperature in the nose and the tail before the first pallet rolls in.
  • The load blocks its own airflow: Even a precooled trailer fails if the pallets strangle the loop. Products need gap space from the walls and a stack height that does not crowd the ceiling. Pallets touching the walls conduct outside heat into the product. Wall loading wrecks temperature uniformity, which is why the back corners so often read warm.
  • The unit is in the wrong mode: Good loading still loses if the reefer is run the wrong way. Sensitech recommends continuous mode for fresh perishables because it makes small adjustments and holds a tighter band. Fuel saver or cycle sentry means that temperatures may drift between cycles, creating hot spots or top freezing on sensitive cargo.
  • The trailer itself is the problem: Sometimes the equipment is the weak link. A torn air chute, a blocked return, a bad door seal, or a damaged wall panel will quietly undo everything else you did right. Don’t overlook this factor: FDA rules require transportation equipment to maintain a certain temperature.
  • Something happened on the road: Finally, when the hardware checks out, look at the trip itself. Sharp spikes, light events, and off-route door openings point to handling rather than mechanics. Extra stops, a long lunch with the doors cracked, a curious receiver who peeked early. Those fingerprints show up in the data when you have the right visibility.

Where should I place a temperature monitor and how do I interpret it?

Finding the root cause is only useful if you are collecting the right data in the first place. Sensitech’s anchor recommendation is the rear pallet, right side facing the door, at eye level. The door end runs warmest, the spot is repeatable, and a receiver can retrieve the device without tearing the load apart.

How can I turn temperature alerts into a repeatable response process?

A good alert tells you a pallet is warming up. It doesn’t tell you who to call, what to say, or whether the driver can still do anything about it. That silence between the ping and the fix is where loads are lost, while the sensor and the software sit back, satisfied they did their jobs.

Five steps keep that from happening:

  1. Write the SOPs before you need them: Put precooling, loading inspection, operating mode selection, and monitor placement into documented procedures your team follows on every load. An SOP you invent at 2:00 a.m. during a claim is not a sound SOP.
  2. Assign every alert type an owner and a next action: A temperature excursion, a door-open event, and a late-stage spike should each have a name attached—and a specific first move. Ambiguity is how products spoil in a parking lot while four people debate who calls the driver.
  3. Investigate with context, not just a number: Pull the lane, commodity, sensor placement, loading photos, reefer mode, door-open log, and trailer condition before drawing conclusions. A 48°F spike means one thing on a hot Phoenix dock and something very different on a mountain pass at night.
  4. Close the loop in writing: Document what happened, what the team did, and whether it worked. Patterns only show up when you can compare last Tuesday’s load to the one from three months ago—without relying on anyone’s memory.
  5. Let the system do the escalating: A workflow engine built on triggers, conditions, and actions can route the right alert to the right person, escalate when nobody responds, and skip the ones that do not need a human. Knowing why the reefer temperature and the pulp drifted apart only matters if the response happens fast enough to save the load.

Key Takeaway

For DRC members, temperature-related disputes often hinge on questions of handling, documentation, and accountability.

By understanding how refrigerated trailers function and by implementing consistent procedures for loading, monitoring, and responding to temperature events, companies can reduce risk and strengthen their position when issues arise.

If you have any questions about the article and would like to learn more, our team at the DRC is here to assist you. We value your inquiries and are eager to provide support. Click here to proceed.

Verified by MonsterInsights