Categories
Uncategorized

Membership Update for July 2026

Summary: Membership Update

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) welcomed 6 new members in July 2026. Additionally, some existing members have changed their membership status. Scroll below for more information.

Welcome New Members

BAKHSHI GLOBAL INC. (Also d/b/a MNB Cash and Carry) ON Canada
EPIC PRODUCE SALES, LLC AZ United States
LADYMEX GROWER INC. TX United States
SS FRESH PRODUCE (A d/b/a of 17909632 Canada Limited) ON Canada
SUPERMARCHÉ AURÈS INC. QC Canada
TROPICAN CAPITAL INC. QC Canada

DRC Membership Change in Status

As of July 31st, 2026, the following organizations no longer hold a DRC membership:

9468-9247 QUEBEC INC., QC, Canada
CANA PACKING INC., NS, Canada
DIRTY LAUNDRY VINEYARD LTD., BC, Canada
EVER TRU FARMS, ON, Canada
EXPERTS GEOCONSEILS INC (Faisant également affaire sous EGC), QC, Canada
HATTI FOODS INC., ON, Canada
HUMBER HOLDINGS CORP., SK, Canada
J P MARKET INC. (Also d/b/a J P Market), ON, Canada
NAB GLOBAL SERVICES (A d/b/a of Joshua Agyemang Badu), AB, Canada
NUTERRA (A d/b/a of Torobunch-Pro Inc.), QC, Canada
PIÑALES DEL CARIBE GAC SA, Limón, Costa Rica
SANTIS PRODUCE LLC., TX, United States
VF TRADE FRESH INC., ON, Canada
VIRSA TASTES (A d/b/a of Jaswinder Singh), ON, Canada
XATLANTIC ENTERPRISES INC., ON, Canada
YYY FOODS PROCESSING INC., BC, Canada

About the DRC

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) is a not-for-profit membership-based entity whose core work is business-to-business commercial dispute resolution for the fresh produce industry. The DRC serves as a referee between parties when a purchase and sale do not go according to plan. Members adhere to a common set of trading standards and member responsibilities that promote fair and ethical trading for produce entering the North American marketplace. In Canada, membership in the DRC is a regulatory requirement to trade fresh fruits and vegetables (i.e., buy, sell, import, or export) unless exempt under the regulations. The DRC has members in 19 countries, and membership continues to grow annually. Anyone exporting fresh fruits and vegetables to Canada must sell to a member of the DRC.

In addition to its Operating Rules and Trading Standards, the DRC offers a comprehensive, tailored suite of tools to build members’ knowledge and capacity to avoid or resolve disputes. The DRC provides education, mediation, and arbitration services, and can impose sanctions and disciplinary actions on members who fail to conduct business in accordance with the terms of their membership agreement.

The DRC has resolved claims worth more than $105 million. Although arbitration is available, 80% of these claims have been settled in an average of 26 days through our informal consultation and mediation services. Arbitration awards are court-enforceable in countries that are signatories to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards or subsequent conventions.

For more information about our members and membership with the DRC, click here.

Categories
Uncategorized

The Value of Customs Brokers

The Risks of Navigating Customs Without Expertise

Navigating customs regulations is one of the most complex and high-risk aspects of global trade, especially in the fresh produce industry, where timing is critical. For businesses importing or exporting goods, even small errors can bring costly delays, penalties, or spoiled shipments. This is why many companies rely on customs brokers to manage documentation and regulatory requirements, helping shipments move quickly across borders.

What a Customs Broker Does

Whether you are new to importing and exporting or operating without a dedicated logistics team, a customs broker can help simplify the process and keep your supply chain running smoothly. Over the years, customs brokers have become more than facilitators in getting commodities across borders. Depending on the level of service required, they may assist with:

  • Collecting, reviewing, and assessing documentation.
  • Determining taxes, duties, classifications, and valuation.
  • Submitting declarations on behalf of the importer.
  • Using their experience to help you grow your business.

Additionally, customs brokers provide educational services that inform importers and exporters how to import into Canada or the USA. These services include information on INCOTERMS, CFIA and FDA-regulated goods, product classification, and Non-Resident Importers. For example, Pacific Customs Brokers (PCB) has created an informative learning center with valuable trade resources for businesses, importers, and exporters: https://learningcenter.pcb.ca/.

Customs brokers stay up to date on policy and regulatory modifications. They use advanced technology, professional expertise, and customized trade solutions to ensure every shipment is managed and declared in compliance with Customs requirements, minimizing loss or penalties and helping secure passage through Customs.

Why Hiring a Customs Broker Makes Business Sense

In today’s global trade environment, many moving parts are often too complex to manage, let alone understand, without the proper tools. Customs brokers help businesses stay focused on their core activities by navigating these complexities.

Hiring a customs broker makes excellent business sense, prepares you for the unexpected, and gives you peace of mind to protect your business and prevent a potential trade dispute.

How the DRC Can Help

Even with expert guidance, disputes over quality, payment, or contract terms can sometimes occur. In these situations, the Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) provides industry-specific support to help resolve conflicts and keep your business relationships on track.

Should you encounter a dispute or need guidance on resolving issues in your fruit and vegetable trade, the DRC can provide trusted support through membership. 

Categories
Uncategorized

Arbitration Decision Brief: Accurate and relevant notes on the Bill of Lading (BoL) are crucial when submitting a claim

Dispute regarding elevated pulp temperatures upon arrival

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) has developed a series of articles summarizing past arbitration decisions. These articles will help members understand how the DRC Dispute Rules and Standards (R&S) apply in a dispute.

The DRC Dispute R&S states that all DRC arbitrations are private and confidential. As such, the names of all parties, including arbitrators and companies, are not included. A reminder that the DRC’s sole role is to administer the arbitration process; the DRC does not participate in any hearings. Therefore, this summary is based solely on the arbitrator’s written decision and may not reflect important information shared with the arbitrator through written briefs or verbal testimony.

ABSTRACT

The arbitration decision addresses a dispute between parties from Canada. The dispute arose when the Respondent failed to pay five (5) freight invoices within the agreed payment terms. The Respondent claimed that one shipment was received at high temperatures, which led to the withholding of payment on four (4) other invoices.

The arbitrator determined that the Respondent failed to provide sufficient evidence that the load in question arrived with high pulp temperatures due to exposure to undesirable transport temperatures.

This summary provides an essential overview of the arbitration decision and its implications for international commercial disputes.

CASE: DRC File #19418 – Parties Domiciled – Canada

SUMMARY OF FACTS (SOF):

The Claimant is demanding payment for five (5) freight invoices that involved the carriage of the Respondent’s produce to the Respondent. These transactions took place between January 23, 2015 and March 11, 2015.

Respondent is claiming that there was damage to one of the shipments.

Claimant has offered, in an email, a final settlement in the amount of a $4,000.00 adjustment to their invoices to resolve the matter with immediate payment to be issued accordingly.

Claimant is seeking a total of USD$30,700.00, which includes USD$2,200.00 Arbitration Filing Fees.

Respondent has not stated their losses in any manner. Respondent has simply stated, “We are attaching all the documents and also the emails which they were trying to negotiate with us, and they are trying to offer us a small amount of money that was for settlement in this case. We are defending according to the CFIA Report.”

STATEMENT OF CLAIM

Claimant has supplied copies of signed bills of lading (BoL’s) on all five (5) shipments with the exception of the BoL for invoice #17294, dated January 28, 2015, that had a “Hi” temperature notation on arrival. There were no other notations on the signed delivery receipts for the other four (4) shipments.

STATEMENT OF DEFENCE TO STATEMENT OF CLAIM

Respondent’s total Statement of Defence in this matter was quoted above in the Summary of Fact, and the arbitrator will repeat it again here. 

“We are attaching all documents and also emails which they were trying to negotiate with us and they were trying to offer us a small amount of money that was settlement this case. We are defending according to CFIA Report.”

Respondent has not accounted for any losses by virtue of an account of sale, dump or donation certificates and/or any other form of defined notice of loss.

SUMMARY OF ARBITRATOR’S ANALYSIS AND REASONING

The supporting documentation the Respondent has submitted clearly references BoL#17771, which was signed completely clean and free of protest on arrival.

The BoLs do not specify a desired temperature while in transit, but the Claimant’s invoices state that 35°F is to be maintained.

The BoL with the “Hi” temperature notation was on a shipment in February 2015, BoL# 17294.

Therefore, it appears that Respondent is claiming losses on a properly delivered shipment (BoL# 17771) and not on the shipment that arrived with high temperatures. (BoL# 17294)

Invoice# 17294 had 15 different items on the load. That being said, there are four (4) CFIA Inspection certificates submitted by the Respondent for only four of those items. Two certificates show normal pulp temperatures (Gai Lan: 34.5°F; Baby Bok Choy: 34-35°F). One certificate for Yu Choy Sum shows 37.2°F. Recommended temperatures for this product must be assumed to be as stated on Claimant’s invoices, as 35°F. Given that it is only warmer by 2°F, one would not expect the damage to be too severe, if any. The other certificate for Yu Choy Mieu shows 37.2-39.5°F, which might be considered a little on the warmer side.

Three of the certificates show large percentages of “limp and pliable,” and the 4th certificate shows “bruising and wilting”. There are four (4) varieties of vegetables highlighted as the damaged goods in question on the invoice from the Respondent’s supplier in Texas. The other 11 varieties have not been highlighted nor inspected as per the submitted documents.

The extent of the damages cited by CFIA on these 4 items could possibly be attributed to poor shipping condition at the time of shipment. In addition, the temperatures during shipment did not affect 11 items or 73% or the load.

Respondent is claiming on a load that was received without objections. Respondent did not claim on the load that was protested for “Hi” temperatures. Included in the Respondent’s documents is a temperature recording tape; however, a temperature recording device with a serial number or tape number is not documented or identified to verify which shipment this tape belongs to. Further to that, the tape submitted reflects the in-transit temperature of 32-33°F.

There is, however, an email that the Respondent submitted where it appears there had to be some discussions about temperature and losses.

Claimant submitted an email dated June 10, 2015, suggesting splitting a $22,136.00 loss three ways. There is no indication whether this loss was USD$ or CAD$.

Furthermore, Claimant offered only a credit of $3,000.00 (no mention of currency) and then finally raised the offer to $4,000.00 with immediate payment of the balance due.

In my opinion, this email does not present itself as an admission by the Claimant to causing any damage; more so, it represents a token of trying to resolve a problem and move forward.

Regardless of any of the commentary provided herein, Respondent is claiming on a shipment that was signed free and clear on arrival.

Respondent has not submitted any claim or documentation to substantiate the claim, on the only shipment that had a notation as to “Hi” temperatures. Therefore, the arbitrator concluded there were no objections or consequences from that shipment arriving with “Hi” temperatures.

ARBITRATOR’S SUMMARY DECISION

The Arbitrator ruled in favor of the Claimant. Respondent must remit to Claimant the amount of USD$30,700.00 within 30 days of the date of this decision.

DRC COMMENTS

It’s essential to understand your responsibilities as the receiver to ensure you have the necessary documentation and make accurate annotations. This will help you support your claim in case any issues arise with the received product.

As a receiver, your responsibilities include the following:

  1. Taking Pulp Temperatures: Measure the temperature of the product upon arrival, before and during unloading the truck. If you notice any undesirable temperatures, collect the temperature recorders, document their location, and load the product back
  2. Request a temperature and condition inspection as soon as possible.
  3. Documenting on the Bill of Lading (BoL): If you receive the product under protest, clearly indicate the reasons for this on the BoL. Additionally, request a download from the reefer unit.
  4. Addressing Missing Temperature Recorders: If the shipper includes one or more temperature recording devices with the load, but none are found upon arrival, you must document the missing recorders and address this issue with the carrier.
  5. Notify the carrier and the shipper of a potential claim.

By following these steps, you can ensure proper notice is provided to the shipper and the carrier.

Another important aspect of this decision is that, when there are multiple transactions between the parties and an invoice is in dispute, payments on invoices that are not in dispute should not be withheld until the dispute is resolved unless there is an agreement between the parties.

According to the DRC Trading Standards, all members are required to meet their financial obligations by paying invoices within the agreed payment terms. If no specific payment terms have been established, payments should adhere to the DRC Trading Standards. Undisputed invoices cannot be withheld unless there is an offsetting agreement between the parties, including the transportation company.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES

To access the full redacted arbitration decision, click here.

DRC Transportation Standards

Solutions Newsletter Articles
• Importance of Documenting Temperatures
• Withholding payment of an undisputed amount: Tips for Better Business Practices
• Arbitration: Top 3 Reasons Parties Fail to Prevail

Categories
Uncategorized

Membership Update for June 2026

Summary: Membership Update

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) welcomed 12 new members in June 2026. Additionally, some existing members have changed their membership status. Scroll below for more information.

Welcome New Members

0920161 B.C. LTD., BC, Canada
17359250 CANADA LIMITED, ON, Canada
ABRASH ENTERPRISES INC. (Also d/b/a Andrews Brothers Inc.), Michigan, United States
CANADEXOTIC / CANADEXOTIQUE (Faisant également affaire sous, QC, Canada
DUTCHYN FARMS LTD., ON, Canada
HEADSTART DIGITAL SOLUTIONS INC. (Also d/b/a Headstart foods), BC, Canada
IMPORT EXPORT SEAPASS INC. / SEAPASS TRADING INC., QC, Canada
LATIN CORE INC., ON, Canada
PARMJIT DHALIWAL, BC, Canada
TIERRAMIGOS TRADING & LOGISTICS INC., ON, Canada
VIET THAI GREEN PRODUCE LTD., BC, Canada
YC FRESH PRODUCE INC., BC, Canada

DRC Membership Change in Status

As of June 30, 2026, the following organizations no longer hold a DRC membership:

1000971951 ONTARIO INC., ON, Canada
9487-2181 QUEBEC INC., QC, Canada
BLACK CHROME TRADING INC., ON, Canada
BULK AND BLOOM DISTRIBUTION INC., ON, Canada
EINAI IMPORT-EXPORT INC., QC, Canada
ELISUR ORGANIC S.A.C., Junín, Peru
GMSY CANADA LTD., ON, Canada
GREWAL & SONS ENTERPRISES INC., BC, Canada
I M C ENTERPRISES LTD., BC, Canada
MADHURAM PHARMA COMPANY LTD., BC, Canada
MEXI/CANA FRESH QUALITY PRODUCE CORPORATION, BC, Canada
ODECO TRADING (A d/b/a of 6396577 Canada Inc.), ON, Canada
RV FAMILY PRODUCE LTD., ON, Canada
SAM IMPEX INC., QC, Canada
SDH GLOBAL CORP., ON, Canada
SK ORGANICS FRUITS S.A.C., Callao, Peru
SOMERFIELD FARMS LLC, NC, United States
UGARIT MARKET (A d/b/a of 2713796 Ontario Inc.), ON, Canada
VENUSCA GLOBAL CORPORATION, ON, Canada
ZURGROUP S.A., Región Metropolitana, Chile

Expulsion Notice 

GREWAL & SONS ENTERPRISES INC. was expelled from the DRC membership effective June 23, 2026, for failing to meet its debts as they came due and for failing to provide the requested information.

About the DRC

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) is a not-for-profit membership-based entity whose core work is business-to-business commercial dispute resolution for the fresh produce industry. The DRC serves as a referee between parties when a purchase and sale do not go according to plan. Members adhere to a common set of trading standards and member responsibilities that promote fair and ethical trading for produce entering the North American marketplace. In Canada, membership in the DRC is a regulatory requirement to trade fresh fruits and vegetables (i.e., buy, sell, import, or export) unless exempt under the regulations. The DRC has members in 19 countries, and membership continues to grow annually. Anyone exporting fresh fruits and vegetables to Canada must sell to a member of the DRC.

In addition to its Operating Rules and Trading Standards, the DRC offers a comprehensive, tailored suite of tools to build members’ knowledge and capacity to avoid or resolve disputes. The DRC provides education, mediation, and arbitration services, and can impose sanctions and disciplinary actions on members who fail to conduct business in accordance with the terms of their membership agreement.

The DRC has resolved claims worth more than $105 million. Although arbitration is available, 80% of these claims have been settled in an average of 26 days through our informal consultation and mediation services. Arbitration awards are court-enforceable in countries that are signatories to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards or subsequent conventions.

For more information about our members and membership with the DRC, click here.

Categories
Uncategorized

The Value of DRC Solutions Articles: Practical Knowledge for Confident Trade

In today’s fast-moving fresh produce industry, access to clear, reliable information is essential. One of the ways the Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) supports industry members is through Solutions, a newsletter that educates, informs, and promotes best practices across the supply chain.

For exporters, importers, growers, packers, shippers, wholesalers, retailers, carriers and transportation intermediaries, Solutions provides practical guidance to help businesses navigate challenges and trade with confidence.

Solutions: A Practical and Trusted Resource

Each Solutions article focuses on real-world issues, offering clear and relevant information that can be applied in day-to-day operations. Whether explaining DRC Trade Standards or highlighting common disputes, the content is designed to be both practical and accessible.

Supporting the Supply Chain

Solutions reflect the diverse needs of the fresh produce industry, delivering insights that help stakeholders prevent disputes and manage contract expectations, transportation liabilities, and compliance. With actionable tips, articles support better decision-making, reduced risk, and stronger trading relationships.

Reinforcing the Four Pillars of Trade

A key focus of Solutions is strengthening the understanding of the DRC’s four pillars of trade standards:

  • Trading Standards
  • Transportation Standards
  • Good Arrival Guidelines
  • Good Inspection Guidelines

Through practical examples, members gain a clearer understanding of their roles and responsibilities. By strengthening knowledge in these areas, Solutions contributes to greater transparency and consistency in the fresh produce trade.

Learning and Prevention

Arbitration case studies provide valuable insights into how disputes arise and how they are resolved, helping members identify risks and improve their practices. At the same time, Solutions emphasizes prevention through clear trading terms, proper documentation, and effective communication—while also offering guidance when disputes do occur.

Explore all Solutions articles at: https://fvdrc.com/resources/Solutions/

A Resource You Can Rely On

Subscribe to Solutions and turn knowledge into action,
so you can continue to trade with confidence.

Categories
Uncategorized

Implications of Dealing with the Wrong Legal Entity

A recent arbitration case highlighted an important but often overlooked issue: ensuring that the legal entity named in a contract is the same legal entity that holds a membership with the Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC).

In this case, both the claimant and the respondent were DRC members. However, the written contract identified the claimant using a company name that did not match the claimant’s legal name registered with DRC. Although the ownership and personnel behind both names were the same, the contract itself referred to a different legal entity.

The claimant argued that DRC should still have jurisdiction because the respondent “knew” they were dealing with a DRC member and that the incorrect name in the contract was merely an oversight.

The arbitrator disagreed. DRC By-laws and Dispute Resolution Rules clearly state that jurisdiction applies only to disputes between DRC members. It is the responsibility of the parties to ensure that the legal entity named in the contract is a member of the DRC. The contract also lacked a DRC arbitration clause, which could have extended jurisdiction to a non-member entity. As a result, the arbitrator found that DRC had no jurisdiction over the dispute.

While this is only a summary of the case, it underscores a critical point: DRC membership applies strictly to the legal entity that has been accepted as a member. Membership rights are not transferable, and members must keep their information current.

Key Membership Obligations

DRC By-laws require that:

  • Membership covers only the specific legal entity approved by DRC.
  • Membership rights cannot be transferred to another legal entity, even if ownership is the same.
  • Members must update their membership information promptly when changes occur.

Recommendations for Members

To avoid jurisdictional issues and ensure your transactions are properly covered, consider the following:

  • Multiple legal entities: If you own more than one company and use each for trading, ensure each entity has its own DRC membership.
  • Name or ownership changes: Report any legal name changes, amalgamations, or changes in ownership to DRC’s membership department.
  • Sister companies: Many organizations operate multiple related companies. Some may be DRC members while others are not. Transactions with non-members are not covered. Always confirm the correct legal entity.
  • Shared ownership does not equal shared membership: Common or similar ownership does not extend DRC membership rights across entities.
  • Contracts and marketing agreements: Always verify that the legal names appearing in any written agreement accurately reflect the DRC member entities involved.

This case underscores the importance of correctly identifying legal entities in contractual agreements and keeping your DRC records up to date. Taking these steps can help avoid jurisdictional issues and preserve access to the DRC dispute resolution system.

Categories
Uncategorized

Membership Update for May 2026

Summary: Membership Update

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) welcomed eleven new members in May 2026. Additionally, some existing members have changed their membership status. Scroll below for more information.

Welcome New Members

A&S DISTRIBUTION INC., ON, Canada
AVO VALLEY S DE RL DE CV, Jalisco, Mexico
BHARATFRUITS CANADA (A d/b/a of 15779316 Canada Inc.), ON, Canada
DESANO PRODUCE LTD., ON, Canada
EKRS INTERNATIONAL PRODUCE INC., BC, Canada
FGF FRESH PRODUCE LTD., BC, Canada
HAYER BLUEBERRY FARMS LTD., BC, Canada
LITTLE LEAF PA, LLC (Also d/b/a Little Leaf Farms), PA, United States
MIKHWAN FOODS INC., ON, Canada
VAN GRONINGEN & SONS, CA, United States
VIVA HARVEST INC., QC, Canada

DRC Membership Change in Status

As of May 31st, 2026, the following organizations no longer hold a DRC membership:

A.H. GARDEN PRODUCE INC., ON, Canada
AGUACATES ACUITZIO DEL CANJE S.A. DE C.V. (También haciendo negocios como ADEAC), Michoacan, Mexico
ARRCA LLC (Also d/b/a Arrca), TX, United States
BACATA FOOD GROUP INC., BC, Canada
DNI MOTOR FREIGHT LTD., AB, Canada
DUNE NORDIQUE IMPORT INC., QC, Canada
GLOBAL LIONS CONSULTING COMPANY LTD., BC, Canada
GLYCAN FOOD LIMITED, BC, Canada
GREAT FOODS GLOBAL LTD., MB, Canada
HAO FU FARM LTD., ON, Canada
HE EMPIRE INC., BC, Canada
INTIFRUITS DE MEXICO S.A. DE C.V. (También haciendo negocios como IntiFresh), Jalisco, Mexico
JAY KISAN TRADING INC., BC, Canada
OKANAGAN SUNSHINE. (A d/b/a of Okanagan Sunshine Fruit Sales), BC, Canada
PAISANO PRODUCE LLC, TX, United States
QUAILS’ GATE VINEYARDS ESTATE WINERY LTD., BC, Canada
REDFROG ENTERPRISES LTD., BC, Canada
TAYLOR FARMS RETAIL, INC., CA, United States
THULASI INC., ON, Canada
UNFI Canada, Inc., BC, Canada

About the DRC

The DRC is a non-profit membership-based organization whose core work is business-to-business commercial dispute resolution for the fresh produce industry. The DRC serves as a referee between parties when a purchase and sale do not go according to plan. Members adhere to a common set of trading standards and member responsibilities that promote fair and ethical trading for produce entering the North American marketplace. In Canada, membership in the DRC is a regulatory requirement to trade fresh fruits and vegetables (i.e., buy, sell, import, export) unless accepted by the regulations. Today, the DRC has members in 16 countries outside North America, and membership continues to grow annually. Anyone exporting fresh fruits and vegetables to Canada must sell to a member of the DRC.

In addition to its Operating Rules and Trading Standards, the DRC offers a comprehensive, tailored suite of tools to build members’ knowledge and capacity to avoid or resolve disputes. The DRC provides education, mediation, and arbitration services, and can impose sanctions and disciplinary actions on members who fail to conduct business in accordance with the terms of their membership agreement.

The DRC has resolved claims worth more than $105 million to date. Although arbitration is available, 80% of these claims have been settled in an average of 26 days through our informal consultation and mediation services. Arbitration awards are court-enforceable in countries that are signatories to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards or subsequent conventions.

For more information about our members and membership with the DRC, click here.

Categories
Uncategorized

When Timing is Everything: Arbitration Lessons on DRC Claim Filing and Product Inspections

Dispute over the limitation of the claims period and the timely inspection request.

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) has developed a series of articles summarizing past arbitration decisions. These articles will help members understand how the DRC Dispute Rules and Standards (R&S) apply in a dispute.

The DRC Dispute R&S states that all DRC arbitrations are private and confidential. As such, the names of all parties, including arbitrators and companies, are not included. A reminder that the DRC’s sole role is to administer the arbitration process; the DRC does not participate in any hearings. Therefore, this summary is based solely on the arbitrator’s written decision and may not reflect important information shared with the arbitrator through written briefs or verbal testimony.

ABSTRACT:

The arbitration decision addresses a dispute between parties from Canada. The dispute arose when the Respondent did not pay an invoice within the agreed payment terms. The Respondent contended that the Claimant’s claim was submitted outside the limitation period. Additionally, the Respondent claimed that as the receiver/buyer, they fulfilled their obligations in a timely manner after receiving the product, which they stated arrived in a deteriorated condition.

The arbitrator determined that the Respondent did not successfully prove that the Claimant’s claim was filed outside the limitation of claims period, and the Respondent failed to demonstrate that an inspection was requested and performed in a timely manner to show the product failed to meet DRC Good Arrival Guidelines.

This summary provides an essential overview of the arbitration decision and its implications for international commercial disputes.

CASE: DRC File #20568 – Parties Domiciled – Canada

SUMMARY OF FACTS:

According to the transportation entry/manifest and bill of lading dated May 15, 2019, a shipment of 600 cases of beef tomatoes (25 LB rounds) was sent from Mexico to Laredo, Texas. Invoice #19005 dated May 15, 2019, indicates that the shipment was sold by the Claimant to the Respondent. The tomatoes were to be picked up by the Respondent, and the load was bonded for transport to Canada. The invoice states that the amount owed for the tomatoes was $9,570.00 US, with billing terms of net 30 days, making the payment due on June 14, 2019.

STATEMENT OF CLAIM:

The Claimant asserts that the Respondent picked up the load at the Claimant’s warehouse in Laredo, Texas. The invoice does not indicate any issues with the tomatoes during the pickup. The Respondent subsequently shipped the tomatoes to Calgary, Alberta, where the truck arrived on May 19, 2019.

Statement of Defence to Statement of Claim

The Respondent purchased the tomatoes (invoice #19005) from the Claimant. The tomatoes were for “X”. The load was picked up in Laredo, TX, on 5/16/2019 and shipped to Calgary, Alberta.

The truck arrived in Calgary on 5/19/2019.

On Tuesday, May 21, 2019, at 8:48 AM, the Respondent emailed the Claimant stating, “The tomatoes aren’t holding up and are very soft. We are calling for an inspection on what we have.”

A Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) inspection was performed on the tomatoes at 10:30 AM on May 21, 2019, at the Respondent’s warehouse, showing:

DefectAverage
Firm Ripe95%
(C) Soft6%
(C) Decay0%
(C) Discoloration4%
(C) Soft areas4%
(P) Scars2%
(C) Sunken areas2%

The following day, another inspection was conducted by the CFIA. The second report noted a slight increase in softness and outlined additional variables not mentioned in the first report; however, only 388 cartons were inspected.

The Respondent argues that the tomatoes did not meet their specifications and that the claim should be barred because it was not filed within the appropriate statute of limitations timeframe provided in the DRC rules.

Reply to Statement of Defence to Statement of Claim

The Claimant states that on 5-28-19, they responded to an e-mail from the Respondent regarding the tomatoes. The Claimant indicates that the inspection barely showed any soft tomatoes. The Claimant indicated that, based on the inspection report, they would probably not issue any credit to the Respondent. The Claimant claims they had no indication that the invoice would not be paid.

The Claimant argues that they never received any accounting of Sale, until the arbitration proceeding was filed. Further, the Respondent didn’t provide any invoices associated with the sale of reworked product. There is no documentation as to final disposition of the tomatoes. There is no documentation as to dumping claims or sales revenues.

SUMMARY OF ARBITRATOR’S ANALYSIS AND REASONING:

First question/issue: Is the arbitration claim barred under the DRC rules?

According to the DRC Rules:

“Article 4 Limitation of Claims.

1) Unless the parties otherwise specifically agree in writing, no Claim may be brought under these Rules by one member against another unless the Claim is notified to the DRC by filing a Notice of Dispute within nine (9) months of when the Claim arose or within nine (9) months of when the claimant ought reasonably to have known of its existence. Failure to file the Notice of Dispute with the DRC within this time is deemed an abandonment of the Claim and shall prevent recovery against another member.”

The record is devoid of communication efforts after May 28, 2019. Neither party submitted further communication evidence.

The Respondent argues that the Statute of Limitations began running on 5-21-19, because they ordered an inspection on that date. Just because someone orders an inspection, doesn’t mean there won’t be some type of resolution on the file. There is no evidence that the invoice would not be paid. How long should a company try to collect on an invoice before they reasonably know it is not going to be paid? It is reasonable in this industry that resolution could take months.

The actual due date for the invoice would have been June 14, 2019. The statute would have started running after June 14, 2019.

The Claimant filled its complaint with the DRC on March 9, 2020, within the 9-month time period. The complaint was filed within the Statutory time limit, and the arbitration will go forward.

Second question/issue: Does the Claimant present a case against the Respondent for recoverable damages?

The complaint states that the Respondent purchased the tomatoes from the Claimant. The Respondent sent the product to Calgary, Alberta. On arrival, the Respondent’s receiving report indicated the product arrived at 7:18 AM on Sunday, May 19, 2019. The report indicated the tomatoes needed grading for soft and colour sorting. Other than that notation, there is no other evidence of a problem with the load of tomatoes. If the tomatoes were deteriorating, an inspection could have been requested on Sunday, the day of their arrival.

Two days later, the Respondent contacts the Claimant and tells them there is a problem with the tomatoes. They have an inspection done that day and another inspection the day after. The first inspection report shows 18% total defects.

In Canada, in absence of an agreement on grade, DRC uses the “Good Arrival Guidelines.”

DRC Good Arrival Guidelines
Tomatoes
15 – total allowable defects
10 – total allowable permanent defects
05 – total allowable same permanent defect
10 – total allowable same single defect
05 – total allowable decay

Three days after arrival, the tomatoes fail to meet DRC Good Arrival Guidelines, but only by 2% (permanent defects such as “scars” do not count on no grade contracts). Could this product have met DRC Good Arrival Guidelines if inspected upon arrival?

The record is devoid of further communication between the parties regarding the transaction or payment thereon.

Further, even though the Respondent claims the product was defective and didn’t meet specs, they produced no documentation regarding the disposition of the product. They claim part of the load was dumped, with no documentation to support their claim. What happened to the remaining tomatoes? There is no documentation to support their limited accounting.

Clearly, the Respondent purchased the tomatoes from the Claimant. The invoice has not been disputed. Regardless of other issues, the Respondent failed to prove its case. No evidence of transit temperatures in this FOB sale was [TD2.1] provided; an inspection 2 days after arrival is only marginally out of spec and is completely different than the QC report on arrival. And finally, as already stated, the disposition of the tomatoes is not properly documented.

Regarding “X’s” [TD3.1] involvement, there may have been a separate agreement for the purchase. However, their participation was not well explained and was not a major factor in the decision. The Respondent stated they were “told” to purchase the tomatoes.

This transaction is a buy/sell between the Claimant and the Respondent.

ARBITRATOR’S SUMMARY DECISION

The Arbitrator ruled in favor of the Claimant; the Respondent must pay the Claimant in the amount of $10,248.00 US ($9,570.00 US plus arbitration fee of $678.00 US).

DRC COMMENTS

There are two important issues to address in this case:

1. Importance of submitting your claim within the 9-month limitation Period

The DRC has a limitation period for claims, as outlined in Article 4 of the Dispute Resolution Rules. If you fail to submit a Notice of Dispute within 9 months from the date the dispute arose, you have failed to file a claim in a timely manner and cannot seek recovery through the court system because that claim is deemed abandoned. To avoid missing the deadline, we suggest that our members start counting the 9-month period from the invoice date, the date the product arrives at its final destination, or the date set by payment terms.

2. It is essential to request a federal inspection promptly when receiving a product in deteriorated condition.

If you have a problem with a load, notify the shipper immediately and proceed to request an inspection. According to DRC’s Trading Standards, receivers must request a federal inspection within 8 hours of a product’s arrival by land. Additionally, after receiving a written inspection report, share this information with the shipper within 24 hours.

It is important to note that an inspection conducted more than 2 days after the product’s arrival may not accurately reflect the quality or condition at the time of delivery.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES:

To access the full redacted arbitration decision, click here.

DRC Dispute Resolution Rules – Article 4

Solutions Newsletter Articles

 

Categories
Uncategorized

Membership Update for April 2026

Summary: Membership Update

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) welcomed sixteen new members in April 2026. Additionally, some existing members have changed their membership status. Scroll below for more information.

Welcome New Members

14317939 CANADA INC., QC, Canada
16930361 CANADA INC., ON, Canada
2713406 ONTARIO LIMITED, ON, Canada
2783986 ALBERTA LTD., AB, Canada
BECOME ORGANIC SAC (También haciendo negocios como Befair Bio), Piura, Peru
CANADIAN FOOD CONSULTING AGENCY INC., ON, Canada
CIC (CANADIAN INDUSTRIAL COMPANY) (A d/b/a of 2066225 Ontario Inc.), ON, Canada
FREYR CREEK FARM INC. (Also d/b/a Paradise Hill Farm), AB, Canada
HE GLOBAL FOOD INC., ON, Canada
MBA SALES LLC., WA, United States
ORMA LOGISTICS CORPORATION, BC, Canada
PRODUCTORA DE FRUTAS FINAS MAGDALEA SPR DE RL (También haciendo negocios como Productora de Frutas Finas Magdalena), Colima, Mexico
PRO-SHIELD LOGISTICS GROUP INC., ON, Canada
RIONIYO CORP., ON, Canada
YRV INC., ON, Canada
ZP GLOBAL COMMERCE INC. (Also d/b/a ZP Citrus), ON, Canada

DRC Membership Change in Status

As of April 30th, 2026, the following organizations no longer hold a DRC membership:

AFRICAN FOODWAYS MARKET LTD. (Also d/b/a African Foodways Ma), MB, Canada
ARONA TRADING SA., Lima, Peru
BOLA DE ORO FRESH SPR DE RL DE CV (También haciendo negocios como Bola de Oro), Oaxaca, Mexico
DALEY FARM FRESH PRODUCE INC. (Also d/b/a Daley’s Trucking), ON, Canada
FRACTAL FLEX INC., QC, Canada
FRUITFEAST PRODUCE INC., ON, Canada
GRUPO ARJORAN SA DE CV, Michoacan, Mexico
HIFRUIT TECHNOLOGY INC., ON, Canada
IMPORTATION GLNA INC. (Faisant également affaire sous Audally), QC, Canada
INTERFRESH INC., CA, United States
NATTURALE Y CIA SCA (También haciendo negocios como NATTURALE Y CIA), Cundinamarca, Colombia
PACIN ENTERPRISES INC., BC, Canada
RACCOONADA NUTS AND DRIED FRUITS TRADING INC. (Also d/b/a Raccoonada), ON, Canada
SHEYAPRINCE IMPORT & EXPORT LIMITED, ON, Canada
SPRING VALLEY PRODUCE, INC. (Also d/b/a Produce Connection), AZ, United States
SUNSATION FARMS INC., CA, United States
TOWNSEND FRUIT FARMS INC., ON, Canada
UNITED GROWERS ORGANIZATION INTL INC. (Also d/b/a UGO), ON, Canada
UNITED PRODUCE LTD., ON, Canada
URBAN HARVEST DISTRIBUTORS INC., ON, Canada
VP FRESH PRODUCE LLC, AZ, United States

About the DRC

The DRC is a non-profit membership-based organization whose core work is business-to-business commercial dispute resolution for the fresh produce industry. The DRC serves as a referee between parties when a purchase and sale do not go according to plan. Members adhere to a common set of trading standards and member responsibilities that promote fair and ethical trading for produce entering the North American marketplace. In Canada, membership in the DRC is a regulatory requirement to trade fresh fruits and vegetables (i.e., buy, sell, import, export) unless accepted by the regulations. Today, the DRC has members in 16 countries outside North America, and membership continues to grow annually. Anyone exporting fresh fruits and vegetables to Canada must sell to a member of the DRC.

In addition to its Operating Rules and Trading Standards, the DRC offers a comprehensive, tailored suite of tools to build members’ knowledge and capacity to avoid or resolve disputes. The DRC provides education, mediation, and arbitration services, and can impose sanctions and disciplinary actions on members who fail to conduct business in accordance with the terms of their membership agreement.

The DRC has resolved claims worth more than $105 million to date. Although arbitration is available, 80% of these claims have been settled in an average of 26 days through our informal consultation and mediation services. Arbitration awards are court-enforceable in countries that are signatories to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards or subsequent conventions.

For more information about our members and membership with the DRC, click here.

Categories
Uncategorized

Setting the Standard for Fair, Confident Produce Trade Worldwide

The fresh produce industry operates on a truly international scale, linking growers, shippers, buyers, and sellers across multiple regions. As supply chains stretch and trading relationships expand, the need for dependable, transparent business practices becomes even more critical. The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) supports this evolving landscape by serving as a global reference point for ethical, reliable commerce in the fresh fruit and vegetable industry.

To meet the needs of a complex marketplace, the DRC, a not-for-profit, membership-based organization, provides harmonized trading practices, promotes responsible business conduct, and delivers trusted dispute prevention and resolution services. Together, these elements help companies work with predictable standards and reduce the uncertainties that can arise in perishable‑goods transactions.

Why Members Worldwide Trust the DRC

Membership in the DRC offers practical, day‑to‑day value for exporters, importers, growers, shippers, packers, brokers, wholesalers, and retailers. Joining gives you:

A Global Framework You Can Rely On
Our standards remove ambiguity by offering consistent guidance for domestic and international transactions.
A Fair and Efficient Dispute Resolution System
The DRC offers education and consultation, mediation, and arbitration services through a clear, impartial system, helping members resolve issues early and protect their business relationships.
Increased Credibility and Reduced Risk
Working within a recognized set of rules reduces misunderstandings, delays, and financial exposure.
Stronger Relationships and Repeat Business
Shared expectations build confidence—confidence leads to repeated, long‑term business.

The Four Pillars of DRC Trade Standards

Our framework is built on four core components that guide every stage of a fresh produce transaction. These standards are widely recognized and help simplify trade from origin to destination.

1. Trading Standards

These standards outline contract expectations, responsibilities, timelines, payment terms, and business integrity requirements. They ensure each party enters the transaction with a clear and consistent understanding of its obligations. 

2. Transportation Standards

Because produce quality can be greatly affected by logistics, our transportation standards define best practices for loading, temperature control, carrier responsibilities, and documentation. They help prevent issues related to handling and transit conditions.

3. Good Arrival Guidelines

These guidelines describe what constitutes an acceptable arrival condition, taking into account commodity type, transit duration, and normal deterioration. They provide a practical benchmark that protects both buyers and sellers.

4. Good Inspection Guidelines

When concerns arise, inspections must be objective and reliable. To protect themselves, companies should follow our guidelines to ensure that inspection reports have appropriate evidentiary value regarding the product’s condition at the destination.

Building a Fair, Reliable Global Marketplace

As produce continues to flow through increasingly complex supply chains, the DRC equips companies with the structure, knowledge, and confidence they need to operate successfully. Whether you’re entering new markets, strengthening existing relationships, or looking to reduce risk, the DRC supports a trading environment defined by predictability and professionalism.

Verified by MonsterInsights