Categories
Navigating Disputes

Who Bears the Burden of Proof When a Product Fails to Meet Contract Terms?

Dispute regarding the condition of the product upon arrival and whether the shipments comply with the terms of the contract

The Fruit and Vegetable Dispute Resolution Corporation (DRC) has developed a series of articles summarizing past arbitration decisions. These articles will help members understand how the DRC Dispute Rules and Standards (R&S) apply in a dispute.

The DRC Dispute R&S states that all DRC arbitrations are private and confidential. As such, the names of all parties, including arbitrators and companies, are not included. A reminder that the DRC’s sole role is to administer the arbitration process; the DRC does not participate in any hearings. Therefore, this summary is based solely on the arbitrator’s written decision and may not reflect important information shared with the arbitrator through written briefs or verbal testimony.

Abstract:

The dispute arose when the Respondent failed to pay the Claimant seven invoices within the agreed terms. The Respondent argued that payment was withheld because all seven loads arrived in deteriorated condition, with inconsistent sizing and greening.

The arbitrator found that the Respondent did not prove the product on six of the seven loads failed to meet DRC Good Arrival Guidelines or contract terms, nor that there was mutual agreement to alter the contract terms. The only modification confirmed applied to one specific load.

This summary provides an essential overview of the arbitration decision and its implications for international commercial disputes.

CASE: DRC File #19346 – Parties Domiciled – United States and Canada

Summary of Facts:

Claimant claims that it sold seven lots of medium #1 quality onions to Respondent represented by invoice numbers 132943 ($6,847.50), 132945 ($6,847.50), 132946 ($6,847.50), 133078 ($6,927.50), 133080 ($6,927.50), 133115 ($6,862.50), and 133116 ($6,847.50), and that it is owed $48,107.50 for the onions plus DRC fees and other costs for a total owed of $61,581.06. 

Respondent defends by claiming that all seven lots were defective with decay and had variable sizing and greening.

SUMMARY OF ARBITRATOR’S ANALYSIS AND REASONING:

Respondent acknowledges that it purchased and received all seven lots of onions. (Statement of Defence, paragraph “1”).  Under well-established law, Respondent owes Claimant the full agreed upon purchase prices for each lot less any provable damages.  Respondent has the burden of proof to show a breach of the contract to ship US#1 medium onions, and to establish the amount of its damages.

Invoice Numbers 132943, 132945, 132946, 133080

Respondent provides no evidence to establish a breach of contract with respect to the lots referenced by invoice numbers 132943, 132945, 132946, and 133080.  There are no trouble reports, and, most importantly, there are no inspections showing of the quality and condition of the subject onions on arrival.  Respondent’s repack reports are insufficient evidence to show a breach of contract since they do not show the condition of the onions at the time of arrival.  Without such evidence, Respondent cannot carry its burden of proof.  Thus, Claimant is owed the full amount of the agreed upon prices for these four invoices.

Invoice Numbers 133078, 133115, and 133116

Respondent reported trouble to Claimant on the three lots referenced by invoice numbers 133078 (PO #9764), 133115 (PO #9773), and 133116 (PO #9772), and Claimant responded by generating a “Trouble Notification” for each lot that said: “Onions Received with decay, variable sizing and greening.  Customer will work through product and advise on returns.”  (Exhibit “H”). 

The following email exchange took place between Respondent’s Mr. A and Claimant’s Mr. M over the next few days:  

7/16/14:

Email from Mr. A to Mr. M #133078 [PO #9764]

“J. Load received will require regarding and reworked in order to meet #1 grade required to pack and ship., we will rework the load and advise as to all necessary costs. Please acknowledge. Thank you.”

Email from Mr. M to Mr. A

“This is what I was afraid of. Could you please send an in-house inspection, so I have it for my grower. Once I have that documentation, we can grant full protection.” (Exhibit “L”). [Emphasis supplied].

7/22/14:

Email from Mr. A to Mr. M

“Subject: File #9773 [Invoice #133115] and 9772 [Invoice #133116]

J both of the attached files have arrived with the same problems. We will endeavor to repack regrade and hopefully bring the Onions to a #1 grade to sell. We will handle for your account. Please acknowledge.” (Exhibit “A”).

Email from Mr. M to Mr. A

“Re: File #9773 and 9772

Can you please send a in-house inspection and pictures? I never received a in-house inspection on the last order you asked for protection on either.” (Exhibit “M”). [Emphasis supplied].

Email from Mr. A to Mr. M

“Subject: Onions loads inspections

Label “YYY”

Date received: 07/19/2014

#1: 50.
#2: 32.
#3: 53.
#4: 42.
#5: 58.
#6: 70.
#7: 91.

Total: 396 bad ones out of 7 units.

Average: 56.5/unit. Fruit flies are all over

Inspected 7 – 50lbs bgs.

56.5% defects

Further inspections to follow

The above emails make clear that the parties agreed to amend their original FOB contracts on these three lots to become “full protection” contracts, but that was expressly contingent upon Respondent providing “in-house inspections.” Claimant said that the reason he needed the in-house inspections was: “so I have it for my grower.”

Respondent’s 7/22/14 email was in response to Claimant’s request for in-house inspections. The inspection was problematic: it was unclear which lot it was for, based on a small sample, and lacked defect details. Claimant did not object, so full protection applied. Respondent’s repack report showed a 68.5% loss, so Respondent owes Claimant $2,142 for invoice #133078.

For invoices #133115 and #133116, Respondent did not provide in-house inspections, so the original FOB contract terms apply. Without proper inspections or representative evidence, Respondent cannot prove a breach and must pay in full for these two lots.

Even if Claimant would have been found to have breached its contractual obligations to Respondent with respect to these two lots, Respondent did not provide Claimant with a proper accounting that shows the dates of sales of the repacked onions, the amounts sold, and the prices, and so would be found to have not proven its damages.

Claimant requests an award of interest, and for reimbursement for the DRC administrative fee and arbitrator’s fees in the amount of $2,700. The Arbitrator has the discretion as to whether to award such a request. Here, there is some evidence that Claimant may have breached its contractual obligations regarding the lots that are the subject of invoices #133115 and #133116, particularly the repacking reports. Respondent, though, is being required to pay those invoices in full due to a lack of sufficient documentation, particularly a lack of inspections. This creates the possibility that Claimant is receiving more than it would have if Respondent had properly documented matters. For that reason, the request for interest is denied. The request for reimbursement of the DRC fees, which is an out-of-pocket expense for Claimant, is granted in the amount of $2,700.

Respondent is found to owe Claimant the following amounts:

Invoice NumberAmount Owed
1132943$6,847.50
2132945$6,847.50
3132946$6,847.50
4133078$2,142.00
5133080$6,927.50
6133115$6,862.50
7133116$6,847.50
Subtotal:$43,322.00
DRC Fee:$2,700.00
Total: $46,022.00

Respondent requests a setoff for the claims made by Company C and Company S. There are multiple problems with this claim, including a lack of inspections and the lack of showing that the onions from the lot that is the subject of invoice #133078 are the ones objected to by those receivers. Accordingly, the request for a setoff is denied.

If Claimant breached its contractual obligations regarding one or more of the six lots for which full price is found to be owed, then this will be a harsh result.  Respondent should know that it becomes vital to obtain a proper inspection to show the condition and quality of perishable produce on arrival, or alternatively, to enter into an amended agreement and comply with that agreement. The most reliable inspections are done by trained third parties.  While parties can agree to use an “in-house inspection,” a receiver needs to be sure that such an inspection comes close to applying the standards used in an inspection performed by the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. 

ARBITRATOR’S SUMMARY DECISION:

The Arbitrator reviewed the documents submitted by both parties and submitted his/her decision as follows:

Claimant shall recover from Respondent the sum of US$46,022.00. Respondent is hereby ordered to pay the Claimant US$46,022.00 no later than thirty (30) days from the date of this decision.

DRC COMMENTS:

There are two important issues to address in this case:

1. If the receiver’s intention is to claim damages for breach of contract due to a load received in deteriorated condition, the following steps are essential to meet the burden of proof in the event of a dispute:

  • Prompt Notification: Notify the shipper of an issue as soon as an issue is noticed upon arrival of the load.
  • Request an inspection: Unless a private or in-house inspection is agreed by the parties, request a government inspection within 8 working hours of arrival (excluding Sundays and holidays).
  • Share the Inspection report: Share the inspection results with the shipper within 24 hours of getting the report.
  • Mitigate losses: You must make every reasonable effort to market and sell the product as quickly as possible to minimize losses.
  • Account of Sales: While an account of sales or liquidation report is not required when claiming damages, this is the best method to show how the product was handled and which expenses were incurred due to the breach of contract. Make sure an itemized account of sales or liquidation report is provided.

2. DRC members should note that in both the US and Canada, a federal inspection is required when receiving product in deteriorated condition, unless both parties have explicitly agreed to another arrangement. The party relying on a private or in-house inspection, rather than a government inspection, must prove that such an agreement exists.

ADDITIONAL RESOURCES:

To access the full redacted arbitration decision, click here.

Solutions Newsletter Articles

Need Help Navigating Fresh Produce Trade Disputes?

Contact the DRC for membership information and expert guidance on preventing and resolving disputes. 
Reach out to us today at info@fvdrc.com or visit www.fvdrc.com/contact to discover how we can help you 
trade with confidence anywhere in the world.

Verified by MonsterInsights